There are great games, bad games, fair games... but no matter the quality there will always be those games that get weird treatment even though no one can ever understand... you'll notice these are fairly new games... 5 - Halo - Its got amazing online and thats what most seem to only like, so how come just the one thing keeps it so high? I mean, Microsoft only bought Bungie for this, it lacks soul! 4 - Psyconauts - Yeah it was a crazy funny game but no one want to admit it was one of the least popular games in a long time, didn't stop some reviewers puckering up! When I asked others they said: "O that game, what about it?" They had little as much as idea I did lol! 3 - Shadow of the Colossus - Firstly the game is different in a good way, but the fans... gosh, they latch on to much, it barely sold much in Europe and only won a few awards in comparison to others that year but to them they can use it to vent their anger on other games? WTF is that? And we all know MGS3 had the best ending ever! 2 - God of War - I really liked this game but not as much as everyone else, its was more or less the game of the year in 2005 with like 100 awards, just cheack wiki... didn't think it was THAT good though and IGN give it a 9.8? Tuh, I give it an fair respectable 9.0, didn't seem like the best thing ever... 1 - Half Life 2 - Over 35 game of the year awards?! 35! Thats beaten any other game ever made and I only thought it was a nice squeal to the orignal which by the way I liked better personally, and somehow its even beaten the crap out of all these games you see above... If these games had an ass, it would be red, sore and bone dry... and I don't think thats a cause noting!