Regenerators from Resident Evil 4.

Honestly the entire game is not scary, but the funny thing is, when you encounter these things they scare you more than any other game, ever. They are so freakishly horrible and repulsive - the way they flop through windows and dive from the floor to your neck with their teeth and the way they breathe and move...

Also Crimson Heads personally scare me a fair bit since they are so damned difficult to kill and when you reach over to burn the zombie there is always the question: will he become a crimson as I do this and attack me?

Arhazard

What about the chainsaw guy?

Dark Link and Dark Fox look awesome

Tell me games that might get a 9.5 and prove me wrong.

AvIdGaMeR444

Just look at Super Mario Galaxy's score