[QUOTE="MrGrimFandango"][QUOTE="the-very-best"]

It got 9.0 and Editor's Choice. That's excellent. Has anyone here actually played the full game? Why does Gamespot have to give the same score as all the other reviewers?

It still has a strong chance for GOTY. And there's nothing wrong with the reviewer.

dru26

Ok so its not the same as the rest? HOW DOES A GAME THAT GETS 9.8 ACROSS THE BOARD GET A 9.0 HERE?

Absolute joke.

agreed thats my number one problem with this review, its very strange that he seems to be the only reviewer who has had that problem.

[QUOTE="Killfox"]

Perfect Dark 0 - 9.0

Bioshock - 9.0

Arent these games supposed to be in different leagues???

Ezgam3r

if this is the new standard for gamespot then bioshock is going to be the only AAA this entire year. i think there is such a thing as too high of a standard

[QUOTE="Wanderer5"][QUOTE="Kahuna_1"]

HAHA, over 1100 posts and the game didnt even flop...

Imagine if it got an 8.5..

Reyes360

If that happen then this thread would probably have 3000 posts by now.

not true it would be genicide of Lemmings because we all would commit account sucicide.

yeah pretty much...the thread it would not be very large

[QUOTE="Dualshockin"][QUOTE="remaGloohcSdlO"][QUOTE="Kahuna_1"]

HAHA, over 1100 posts and the game didnt even flop...

Imagine if it got an 8.5..

remaGloohcSdlO

yeah i dint see any zelda was better in terms of account suicides...

you guys were pretty happy with jeff when he gave gears of war a 9.6. :|CaseyWegner

lol, so were cows last gen when ff 10 got a 9.3 or when the original god of war got a 9.3 people complain when we think reviews are unfair. edit: yes unfair is a matter of perceptive everyone does it its not just us was my point

PS3 will wipe the floor with 360 in europe and japan.xjet039

sheesh xjet its funny how you have changed your opinion so much

anyway i still dont think the ps3 is going to win this gen without making the price of console under $300 and its not going to happen unless sony wants to bleed money like no other, sony has some casual games but no casual is going to buy a ps3 for $500 to buy singstar.

If the pc version scores higher all hell is breaking loose. I wouldnt be surprised if there would be a mob outside of gamspot.plat1num913

why? the pc is almost always better than its console counterpart(i am a 360 owner and i will say this)

If Jeff reviews Halo 3, watch out. He seemed to like Bioshock a lot. With Halo 3 he said "It's more Halo."

organic_machine

i know as i was reading his review i was like.. this is a 9? i would hate to see how much negative stuffhe is going toput in 8s and 7s from now on...

Man, I'd love to keep following this thread but 4AMs my bedtime, Just wanna leave by saying this.

Do you think that after seing all the hype surrounding the game from other sources, he got his hopes up for a perfect game? Thus, when he sees flaws in this supposedly perfect game they get to him. This causes him to rate down from 10 rather than up from 1 and by doing this he is just letting the gaming community know that the game isn't quite as perfect as people want it to be, don't get your hopes too high for fear of major disappointment when it isn't quite to your taste (hence his little comment on Halo fans at the end).

Not well written I know but my two cents are worth just as much as yours.

O_OdazX_X

so you are saying he read other reviews and then played the game, reviewed for this site and just glanced over the fact that no other review site talked about a graphical glitch? na i don't think he really read any other reviews at all or at least not in-depth.

please answer me this, lemmings. do you want to be like the sheep or cows or do you want to be above their level?CaseyWegner

well i mean its not like we dont have a reason to complain this wasnt like the tp or Resistance review he made legitimate complaints that were talked about in other reviews, but this review he suddenly encounters a glitch no other site encounters? thats really weird...and we have room to complain about it.