So many of the game on this list just reminded me of how Gamespot's take is so different from my own. I can't stand JRPGs or soullike boring slugfests. Witcher 3, BG3 and MGS are great but the rest I wouldn't play if you paid me.
Mouse and keyboard is superior if you have to aim or use mouselook. Controller is better for platformers. For 1st/3rd person games, I can't imagine using a controller.
artiebuco's comments