Both consoles are good, I got the Xbox one because all my friends got that that's all it really comes down to. Last gen I had a PS3 and PS2 before that.
I have played Halo 5 more than any game on this list. It easily has the highest replay value out of these games. I found Witcher 3 boring just couldn't get into it but I can see why it won GoTY ( very polished and finished game). I can't believe Halo was that low on the list.
Played the beta, some parts were fun some parts were not. After the novelty of the beautiful maps wore off the game was pretty boring and stripped down. I had a blast on battlefront 2 on my ps2 and played that for countless hundreds of hours...good times. It is a bummer, I was hoping it was going to be a big blockbuster game but was disappointed. I will stick to halo 5.
bladev1's comments