i have both. i got gears when it first came out, halo3 when it first came out. i've logged way more time into gears than halo3 but some things are easy to see
Graphics - Gears by a long shot
Single Player - Gears
Co-op - Halo3, 4 man co-op = good time
Multiplayer - Halo3, they've perfected the multiplayer system for xbox live
Replay Value - Halo3, gears was a cake-walk on all difficulty levels, at least halo3 provides some difficult, skulls, and 4 man co-op are all good reasons to replay this game.
neither is a clear-cut winner. each is good at what it does, and each does different things well. neither has a huge negative. personally i like halo3. to me graphics don't make something fun. graphics make you think, "damn this looks real." Is this important? Yes. Integral to fun? Not to me.
Log in to comment