GameFly has really changed the way I buy games. Renting first is a must for me now (that's why I don't own a copy of Two Worlds and other awfulness). Here's my list, what's on yours:

Mass Effect
ESRB: Mature Xbox 360 Releases 11/22/07

Assassin's Creed
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 11/15/07

Naruto: Rise of a Ninja
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 11/1/07

Eternal Sonata
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 9/19/07

Halo 3
ESRB: Mature Xbox 360 Releases 9/25/07

NBA 2K8
ESRB: Everyone Xbox 360 Releases 10/3/07

Final Fantasy Tactics: War of the Lions
ESRB: Teen PSP Releases 10/11/07

Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 10/23/07

Rock Band
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 11/20/07

Brothers in Arms: Hell's Highway
ESRB: Mature Xbox 360 Releases 11/15/07

Too Human
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases TBD

John Woo Presents Stranglehold
ESRB: Mature Xbox 360 Releases 9/7/07

Grand Theft Auto IV
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 3/5/08

WWE SmackDown! vs. RAW 2008
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 11/13/07

Kane & Lynch: Dead Men
ESRB: Mature Xbox 360 Releases 11/15/07

Mercenaries 2: World in Flames
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases TBD

Devil May Cry 4
ESRB: Mature Xbox 360 Releases 1/31/08

Frontlines: Fuel of War
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 1/31/08

Half-Life 2: The Orange Box
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 10/11/07

Medal of Honor: Airborne
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 9/6/07

Dark Sector
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 1/31/08

Sega Rally Revo
ESRB: Everyone Xbox 360 Releases 10/11/07

Castlevania: Dracula X Chronicles
ESRB: Rating Pending PSP Releases 11/15/07

Turning Point: Fall of Liberty
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases TBD

Skate
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 9/13/07

Conan
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 10/25/07

The Club
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 2/7/08

Dark Messiah of Might and Magic
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 2/7/08

FlatOut: Ultimate Carnage
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 10/4/07

Virtua Fighter 5
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 11/1/07

Fatal Inertia
ESRB: Everyone 10+ Xbox 360 Releases 9/13/07

Enemy Territory: Quake Wars
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 11/30/07

Beautiful Katamari
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 10/17/07

Warhammer: Mark of Chaos
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases TBD

Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases 10/25/07

Wheelman
ESRB: Teen Xbox 360 Releases TBD

Heist
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases TBD

.Hack: G.U. Vol. 3 - Redemption
ESRB: Teen Playstation 2 / PS2 Games Releases 9/14/07

NBA Live 08
ESRB: Everyone Xbox 360 Releases 10/2/07

Simpsons
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 11/1/07

Army of Two
ESRB: Rating Pending Xbox 360 Releases 11/15/07

Sounds like you have the "Ice" theme turned on. To check it, click on "Pref" in the top right and go to the "Members Only" section. That's where you can play around with the different themes (I prefer Platinum Dark myself).

Hope that helps.