if it had a wii mote and nun chuk it be perfect. you need something to point at the screen and you need a d-pad/thumsick to move, moving on th spot forward and back is not plausible in small spaces and tiring and annoying after awhile, espeacially on your own. specific commands like reload, duck, melee atack and speacial commands like disarming a bomb or picking someting up could be done by nital

Sonys and microsoft and motion controllers sre hslf hearted in reguards to ps3 and xbox 360. They are dividing their installed base, and even after they are both released they will be more likely not shipped with their respective console as standard.

I think natal and sony motion controllers will have littlr impact this generation, they probably won't see the light of day until christmas 2010, and as a stand alone will cost close to a 100 euros dollars. I think both companies are releasing them to save face when the ps4 and next begin to roll out in 2012 and so on. I think microsoft is going to need a controller for the natal system, and i am wondering how it is going handle proper multiplayer with 4 people moving at the same time, or doing precise movements for games such as call of duty, or wii sports clones. As for sony the wand thing will need a nun chuk equivalent, moving around a 3d environment all the time as a relacement for a d-pad or analog stick is unrealistic.

Wii sports- 7.5

CoD 3 - 7.7

Trauma centre- 8.0

Monkey ball Blitz- 8.4

Xbox 360 FTW!!!!!

Axecident

Disagree. Only a fraction of people buy handhelds in comparison to the number of people who buy consoles. And in my experience, casuals like pretty graphics:)-voodoo_child-