No, its not too Anal Retentive to want to do that. It is, however, too Anal Retentive to organize online petitions to get such a feature added to PSN. Last year, when I first started playing my, then new, PS3 I had no idea what a trophy was. Now I look at them and in some games (LBP) I am obsessed with getting them all. Generally though, it's harmless as is and I save my anal retentiveness for other things.

Get your Portable ID!