NFL 2K5 was better, but Madden 05 sold better. Now They will have been out of the NFL for 5 years, d oyou think they can pickup where they left off and jump past Madden, that seems like a bit of a stretch imo.mischa_bartonYou're right. It would be a stretch but I doubt impossible. I see it this way...2k is about gameplay..realism...And EA is honestly about features. And in basketball 2k won...they sold more...But yeah I understand where you are coming from, 2k has been out of the way. All Pro 2k8 couldnt touch Madden 08. But All Pro 2k8 was a $20 game and when 2k gets the chance to make a NFL, $60 (the more expensive, usually better) football game I think people will have a great time being allowed to, at least, choose again. I do feel 2k will come back strong..how strong? I don't know, just have to wait and see. Will be interesting again to see EA vs 2k on the football field again
gamerzay's forum posts
[QUOTE="sourcerah"][QUOTE="CoiledNewkirk"]false.fail... This years madden has tons of new features that have yet to be implemented in a football game. Makes me wonder if people actually take the time to look at what the game offers before the make their ignorant comments It's pretty obvious they don't Not taking anything from what was said. But yeah THIS YEAR is going to be real good...Still needs a little more..but i admit the features this year are on a newer level (finally) I wanna play a NFL 2k game though, just for some options.. But yeah I'm getting Madden this year and compare gameplay from last year but from the demo...it looks goodSame game every year...... just new rosters.......they should just make 1 madden then have you download the newrosters on your xbox.........from the marketplace
Doomtime
@ DOOMTIME First, I never said madden 2005 was worse than NFL 2K5 I loved madden that year, quite a bit more actually, even though 2k did valiant ...But...looking at how comfortable madden has become it seems sluggish..in my opinion... Second, since we're on history, Live 05 was better than NBA 2k5..but when 2k FINALLY decided to step up they killed Live last season..Not dick riding 2k, they're a good franchise without as much exposure, and have proven to many (since nba 2k9 was number #1, fans and choice) they can outdo EA somewhere. Lastly, it'll be good to have some competition for Madden that way EA can prove again, since they are madden that 2k is not a threat. But by the way EA loss in the basketball setting it will be an interesting battle I want a chance to choose...thats all....Then why did Madden 2005 still outsell NFL 2k5 even though it was only $20? Seriously Come on. Most people that bring up the rights don't know what they're talking about. The NFL came forward and a bidding war ensued so somebody had to win. Even when 2K comes back, it will still take time for them to put a dent into Madden's sales.
Log in to comment