i would choose xcom, but as i wrote in the ps3 category, i think in console categories there should be only exclusives, and in this one the winner will be halo 4, anyone has a doubt of that??

i haven't played dirt, and sonic, the other three i have, and i go with gamespot in this one, but by a really close margin, forza horizon and the new most wanted are two of the best racing games ever

this one was a sure choice, xcom should be the game of the year!!

i haven't played dishonored, so i can't say for sure that it shouldn't have won it, but, by the few videos of gamplay that i saw, i can say that for me sleeping dogs is much better

two of the best fighting games EVER!!

and to @ABEzilla116, please keep it between real fighting games, not that smash boring bros., it gives the chance to win to everyone,but when a first time player beat the hell out of some experience player of the same game, there is something wrong, it is good to have chances against "experts", but in super smash bros.simply there are too much chances, before any speculation, when i first played that game, i was against three more experience players, and i ended second by not much, it is like comparing the age of zombies (psp) with dead rising, or dead island,it is funny,but it will never be as good as the others

a solution to this would be to make groups to new fighting gamers at least in the xbox live and the psn, like a rookie group or like a novice league, although the game style in the new era of fighting games are to soft to the older fighting gamers, for example, i find the street fighter II much harder than the S.F. IV, well in anyway, this style will never be dead