Got ICO. Jesus, this game is overrated. All it is, is flashback (genesis) in 3d. I'll take Prince of Persia over this any day. I've played worse, but 8.5? More underrated than Planescape? Most overrated game since Dino Crisis, IMO.

8.5!!!!!

That means this game is allegedly as good or better than Metal Gear Solid, American McGee's Alice, Xenosaga, Shenmue, Jade Empire, Kingdom Under Fire, Baten Kaitos, Empire Earth, ZOE2, Fatal Frame, every Silent Hill game, Kingdom Hearts, Gothic 2, and my personal favorite, Fear Effect.