My Opinion: Why Fallout 3 is better than New Vegas.
by harry_james_pot on Comments
Something that you're probably heard a lot before, is how Bethesda "ruined" the Fallout series with Fallout 3, and then Obsidian brought the greatness back with New Vegas. I see a lot of people saying that.. and I completely disagree. First of all, I'm not saying that New Vegas sucked or anything like that. In fact, it actually did some things better than Fallout 3. Like iron sights, weapon mods, etc.. But the main thing that NV did better, and most likely why people claim it's the better game, is quest choices. Instead of having to go down a specific route within the narrative of a quest you can choose what you want to do, or who to side with. And sometimes even those choices had multiple ways of doing them. In theory, that's great. But sadly I found most of the quests too boring to really care about the choices they offered. The game world in New Vegas felt empty and lifeless to me. Yeah I know, it's a post-apocalyptic wasteland, it's supposed to feel like that. But that's not really it. Fallout 3 did feel like an actual wasteland. You could see the effects the bombs had on all the environment around you.. The destroyed buildings and highways. It really felt more real, and I was way more immersed in the game world than I did in NV. That whole post-apocalyptic sense was completely absent from NV for me. It was just walking around in the desert and doing boring stuff. I was completely disconnected from the game. I played FO3 in 2008, and NV in 2011. NV was only 2 years ago, but I can hardly remember any quests or locations in the game. And yet I still clearly remember most of FO3. The quests, locations, even the characters. What I'm trying to say here is that NV having choices does not magically make it better. If a game has a great, interesting world that can fully immerse you in it.. If it makes you feel that this world has a soul, you can easily ignore its few flaws. And having a great feature like choices within quests without an interesting world to support it, just ruins the whole thing.
Log in to comment