If you go by user ratings (used those with at least 300+ ratings), the top 5 looks like this-

Ridge Racer


9.0 SUPERB

1,365 ratings | 31 reviews


WipEout Pure


8.9 GREAT

1,942 ratings | 41 reviews


Twisted Metal Head-On


8.9 GREAT

1,557 ratings | 31 reviews


Tony Hawk's Underground 2 Remix


8.9 GREAT

911 ratings | 18 reviews


Hot Shots Golf: Open Tee


8.9 GREAT

534 ratings | 11 reviews
Reddsk

Which is much more realistic, good job dude.