@forester057: Both games were masterpieces of their time and Shadow of the Colossus in particular was one greatest of that generation. That being said, Ico absolutely holds up. its a simple game mechanically, short, and is more satisfying upon multiple playthroughs IMO. SotC on the other hand, has not aged very gracefully. while i still heart that game, the controls are pretty atrocious and it does show its age.
L_Willard's comments