Seeing the newest news about Simon Cowell has left me feeling that there are a lot of shows out there that need to stop while the going is good before this happens to them. I've thought for a while that, with Paula gone, it was only a matter of time before American Idol was finished, but now that Simon is leaving, the show needs to end after this season. I don't want AI to evey try replacing Simon, because they can't. If they do a tenth season, it will be remembered for a long time as the worst season ever. Despite what Randy said, people do watch the show for the judges, particularly Paula and Simon, myself included.
But this got me thinking about other shows which need to end before they get cancelled unceremoniously. Here is my list:
1. Heroes - Heroes tops the list because, even though I continue to watch and (gasp!) like the show, the ratings have been slowly plummeting since season 1, with this season at the show's lowest. I continue to think that Heroes, especially this season, is really good. But most other people don't think so. But because of how well it once did, I really would like the show to end on its own terms in some amazing way before it gets cancelled, because the faithful and real fans deserve it. Maybe Peter actually getting his full on power back and fighting Sylar in an epic battle that results in both of them dying? Sounds good to me.
2. Smallville - Smallville has been on the air for quite some time now and despite the fact that this season has undeniably been their strongest in quite some time, the fact that they lost, not only Kristin Kreuk, but Michael Rosenbaum and the execuive producers as well tells me that it's time for this show to end gracefully and the way it was meant to: with Clark donning the Superman costume and flying for the first time. I'm not saying they're short on material, I just want a satisfying ending before it is too late.
3. Supernatural - The same could be said for Supernatural. I have watched five seasons of this show and season 5, the current season, has by far been the best and I have been very pleased with how they are handling the Apocalypse. But, as has been brought up by many fans, how do you best the storyline which is currently going on? How do you top the Winchester brothers stopping the Apocalypse and killing Satan??? There's just no way to continue a show once they have defeated the most evil entity known to man. So, Eric Kripke, from a fan, stop while the going's good. It's better to go out like Ellen and Jo, with a bang, than limp your way to the finish line on a lackluster season. Because it will be very difficult to top this one.
4. Scrubs - Now this is one show that I am not currently watching and, frankly, am extremely upset is still on. I stuck with Scrubs through to what was supposed to be a series finale. I wrote in my review of that episode that the writers did an amazing job of providing closure while leaving the future wide open for all of the main characters (see: last 5 minutes of finale). But then they ruined it by continuing the series. In med school. Bad idea from the get-go and now, it looks like Scrubs's series finale will forever be besmirched by the retarded offspring it created. Try as they might, the writers could not save this sinking ship. They could have made a spin-off under a different name. I wouldn't have watched it, but I would have been happy. But no, ABC decided to keep the series going and look what happened. Piece of advice, writers, write a finale and give the Scrubs fans something to hold on to. Because if this show gets cancelled without the proper send-off it deserves, I will never forgive you corporate bigwigs.
What do you think? Any shows that should end while the going's good?
Log in to comment