Modern Warfare 2.

I own both and Uncharted win by 5 miles instead of 1. Uncharted looks better period, you would have to be blind not to see that.

That said, Alan Wake still does have awesome graphics.

Xbox LIVE feel more "together" I gues you could say than PSN does. Everything can be accessed faster, and there's party chat. But really, since you have to pay for it I would say PSN is better, even though I think LIVE is a more complete experiance. They both have about the same on the server part, except I have alot less problems with disconnections on PSN. They both have about the same lag. One thing, I've always found that there is more stuff on LIVE, be it movies, tv shows, or demos. payments aside, I'd LIVE would be a tad better because of the exellent service though. With the payments included, there even imo.

I have both btw.

Definately Oblivion. I loved the open world and exploring.

The Lord of the Rings theme is pretty cool

This award was made for Chris:Ptntkng

LOL true.

I'm sure the boulder part helped him secure the win though:P

I like the way Sheva totally OWNED Wesker with her knife at the end of RE5

Chris would be a close 2nd

The bastard is my favorite kind of Boss!
but owning the masochist feels like a bigger winsouleater289

this