i don't think its overrated, and thats just me playing the xbox 360 orange box version. the atmosphere in particular holds up as one of the best realized worlds in video games imo.

I'll get it eventually, it is my favorite series of all time, but there are too many new games coming out for me to invest full price on hd collections. I never played peace walker though, so that should be interesting, heard some good things about it.

Already have it pre ordered for release date delivery from amazon. If i could choose only one game to play all year its gotta fifa, i put countless hours every year since fifa 09.

add me on psn: jcwkings if you want a challenge, im pretty good, in fifa 11 i was ranked in the 20ks legit, no hacking or custom tactics and i only played a couple matches a night. before i traded it in a month ago. my main teams were arsenal if someone picked 5 star teams, but i also used barcelona at times and manchester united and chivas for lower tiered teams. For national teams i always used Mexico.

i agree, fallout 3 sucked along with every other bethesda games i have played. games that are TOO open world just bore me to sleep and have no interesting plots to keep me going.

Im too busy having fun to care, analyze your AA, and textures quality all you want, we'll be over here actually playing games.

i play uncharted for the single player, if the multiplayer is even slightly good its just icing on the cake for me.

tough choice but i will go with metal gear solid 3

honerable mentions: uncharted 2, assassin's creed series, half life 2, portal 2, dead space series, fifa series

assassin's creed series, mass effect has a chance but i have only played the first one recently, waiting to play the second one at a later time.

planet of the apes

Dont get me wrong, its my favorite ip this gen. but when you look at what the game is, its a a game that roots itself in history, with a sci-fi narrative, that at first had no multiplayer, with a first game that had many negative opinions(i liked it), it doesn't treat its players like idiots, and yet its sales rank up there with the biggest shooters and sports games. i think its pretty impressive and gives me hope that not all gamers care about guns, explosions and multiplayer.