...Ok, so it's not that big of a deal.

I'm looking for a good RPG. One that is deep, layered, and sophisticated. I'm not looking for something open-world like Oblivion, because I've played that to death. At the same time, I don't want something too JRPG and annoying like Final Fantasy.

I've personally been looking at Persona (hah!), but that's looking too anime-styled for me. One that I've heavily enjoyed recently is the Mass Effect series (although I wish it was more of a true RPG!), so something along those lines.

General RPG'sI've played:

Mass Effect 1+2
KOTOR
Oblivion
Final Fantasy 12 (got 1/3 of the way through, hated it)
Planescape--Torment
Dragon Age
Mount and Blade

Thanks guys!