Alright, so today I'd like to share with all of you how GameSpot seems to moderate whatever they feel like moderating... in fact I'm gonna share with you some personal messages I had with the person that locked my thread...
So here is the topic I posted in OT: LINK TO MY TOPIC
Here are the messages from my inbox:
[QUOTE="maniamsmart"][QUOTE="DroidPhysX"][QUOTE="maniamsmart"][QUOTE="DroidPhysX"][QUOTE="maniamsmart"][QUOTE="DroidPhysX"][QUOTE="maniamsmart"][QUOTE="DroidPhysX"][QUOTE="maniamsmart"][QUOTE="DroidPhysX"]
Your pro-life post had no objectivity and therefore cannot hold weight.
DroidPhysXWhat?
Your locked thread on aboriton. Your reasoning was fundementally flawed.
Fundamentally flawed?
I don't think that was the case, I believe it was more along the lines of an authoritarian falacy. My thread had a fundemental reason behind it, it had the reason for spreading the reasoning of abortion. Not to mention I had further included a piece of support from an outside resource and shared it with a community of people. Having a poll also made the topic a fundamental discussion in which reasoning could not only be drawn from my piece of supprot but also from the responses of other members that would have stated their opinions.
I'm part of the International Baccalaureate body, and I've written extended essays and discussion topics which are based on reasoning, if anyone would know anything about fundamental reasoning... that would be me.
Now if you would have told me that my posting was disruptive due to the huge paragraph then yes, that would have been a good moderation TOWARDS MY POST, not towards the entire topic.
Seeing as you did not state that, you my friend have exhibited an act of an authoritarian falacy whether it was towards your preferences towards the topic or not...
~maniamsmart
Senior Gamespot Member
I saw no objectivity, no factsand therefore it holds no weight. Are all your essays like this?
Exactly my point for showing an authoritarian falacy, thank you for confirming with me.
And mind you the topic was on Abortion, thus there are no FACTS based on the topic since it is an opinionated topic. If you would like to moderate everything based on FACTS, I suggest you sit in your chair and begin looking over 50% of the topics on the OT board.
~maniamsmart
Senior Gamespot Member
So your opinion on abortion held no weight? Gee, never heard of an arguement against abortion like that.
What? Right now you are making no sense what so ever. And don't try to patronize me with your smart remarks...
I don't even see why I have to argue with you, your obviously not getting my point... you locked my topic due to an authoritarian fallacy... a moderator is not supposed to do that... in fact I doubt you even know what that means... which continues to prove to me that there is no point in even talking to you anymore.
Many of the topics in the OT board do not have facts in them, and they are all opinions... they don't get locked. My topic was no different from others... opinions vary by personal perspective... there is no value or weight for an opinion since it is a statement based on someone's own beliefs.
I think you need to review your moderation guide again because there was no purpose in locking that thread. The only reason that you could defend yourself with is that my first post had ahuge paragraph that could have been seperated... you did not even let the topic stay open long enough for me to do that. Your reasoning for closing the topic because it had "no weight" is a pathetic reason and if you want to defend yourself with that reason then please do me a favor and lock all topics in the OT board that do not contain facts and apparently hold no weight.
Have a good day sir, you've already wasted enough of my time, I thought a "moderator" such as yourself would understand and have an open mind, but apparently I was wrong.
~maniamsmart
Senior Gamespot Member
First off I was arguing about the legality of abortion.
And secondly...I'm not a moderator.
Legality? Wow... I don't what your trying to prove... let me ask you something... are you just bringing words out of your head that may sound smart and big to defend your argument? The legality of abortion is different in every country, thus making it a good topic for discussion... if you were arguing the legality of abortion then why in the world did you lock the topic in the first place?! Post your argument in the thread.
And if you're not a moderator, then that's even worse, then you're completely using an authoritarian fallacy to lock the thread
~maniamsmart
Senior Gamespot Member
I already did ;)
Now take a look at this topic, it has the same purpose and the same topic and it is not locked...: LINK TO THE TOPIC
I don't get it... the mods these days are messed up, or at least the one I dealt with...
Log in to comment