It really comes down to personal preference. As for me I have gotten 2K8, i'm disappointed there is no franchise mode but I can live. Making a team and going online is tons of fun. League support is fantastic. I just love playing other people online, I have not experienced slow down at all as of yet. Madden of course will have its huge franchise mode. I must say though that the gameplay in 2K8 is the best football gameplay I have ever played. All quarterbacks feel different which is amazing. All players basically have their own distinct feel, it's great. At least rent it, you won't regret it.