sorry but you guys really havent tested each controller enough. The Dual Chock 3's analog sticks feel way better then the sixaxis. Trust me i have two japanese Dual Shocks ive had them since it came out and the Sixaxis analog sticks fail in comparison. just test it out for yourself. in cod4 you can make precise movements with the Dual Shock 3 and the sixaxis feels rubberbandish (i guess thats the only way to explain it) you have to test it out yourself to feel the difference.