It depends on who you are, I prefer the 360 due to its texture quality, especially asphalt in gta 4, also it shines in the detail in scenery such as plants and simple enivorments like rocks and walls. The ps3 has fantastic particle effects like the smoke in call of duty 4 is incredible. It also has great draw distance which I also like to add the anti aliasing which works well at distance but 360 looks better closer. Also dynamic lighting is excelent on both, but depth in dynamic grass in the 360 is far superior in madden