Wow was my first impression off. I just played farther in the game and it is awesome. I can't believe I said that about this game. I am playing as a good guy, but once I started shooting gargoyles, finding silver keys, beating the crusible, giving money to barnibus to help westcliff, and starting insane combos, and killing hollow men in three steps (shoot their weapon, shoot their head, shoot them dead), and getting further in the story. It is definitly a 9.5. AWESOME!!!!!