It's official. Either they have extreme standards for games, or they're strongly biased towards the Wii. I haven't seen a Wii game get at least a score of more than 9 save for Wave Race 64, RE4 and WarioWare.....All the AAA titles from Nintendo are being dissed by them...next thing you know, Phantom Hourglass gets less then 8.5, Dewy's Adventure will have a 7.0, Mario Galaxy won't score better than Zelda, and the unthinkable might happen to our beloved SSBB(Melee got an 8.8 back then).......
Maybe they aren't biased, but if I see GTA 4, Halo 3, MGS4, Rock Bandand Spore get near-perfect GS scores way above 9.....