I had mixed feelings about it. Although I'm not horribly upset that John dies and we have to play as Jack, (Who really isn't that bad), its the WAY it all happened. Why the heck did John not go out the other side of the barn and ride off? Why did he run out into that huge crowd of enemies when he knew they were there? Why is there no explanation for why they randomly come to his house and gun him down? Why are there no events leading up to it? (Wow, I shot a bear, and some wolves, and herded cattle, and--OH MY GOD THE US ARMY IS RAIDING MY HOUSE). It doesnt explain why Abigail dies, either. None of the previous characters have any relevance to it, (What if Bonnie shows up and saves John, or maybe Irish or Landon Rickets comes in and shoots em all down!) The implied "aftermath" is not bad, but the end sequence itself is a horrible piece of poo.
Log in to comment