ME2 for gameplay and ME1 for story.

I voted ME2.

@mdk12345: Being a gamer isn't the problem. It's how you portray that aspect of yourself to the world that could be an issue, depending on who you're dealing with. You can love gaming, and yet not have your entire house filled with gaming cartridges, consoles, and other memorabilia. Fanaticism about ANYTHING isn't attractive.