ok well i wouldn't go that far to say that just because there rookies those ratings are to high. Do you remember madden nfl 07? mario williams and reggie bush were rated like 87 overall i believe.

My rookie ratings top 6 and why

jake long- 83- because he has size, strength, and is one hell of a run blocker

Chris Long- 83-because he has a non-stop motor, good agility, good strength, ok speed, a great tackler, and great Genes (Howie Long Hall of Famer)

Matt Ryan- 80- ok this rating was a push because I truly believe that matt ryan is nothing but hype, they just want to forget about michael vick

Darren McFadden- 87- dude this guy is a phenom, a little bit of reggie bush, a little bit of adrian peterson and a little bit of LT, you can't get any better then that

Glenn Dorsey- 84- arguably the best defensive linemen to had ever come out of college. This guy reminds me of a future hall of famer in Warren Sapp

Vernon Gholston- 83- this guys is a freak and a relentless pass rusher a very good fit for a 3-4 defense