On a recent edition of the hotspot podcast several of the pannel refered to the new Violent Video Games health and labeling act by CA rep. Joe Baca specifically calling out the fact that there is no real "causal" relationship between video games and violent or agressive behavior. Well I hate to differ and would not do so if I had not read the study by the Pediatrics Journal (link below to free PDF DL). It remains to be debated if such a "causal" relationship exists between video games and behavior as does between alcohol and birth defects. however, we dont put such subjective warnings on alcohol as George Carlin would put it "drinking to much of this will turn you into the same a-hole your father was." Further, I think the real issuse is not whether or not violence in media can or cannot be linked to agressive behavior. But rather that agressive behavior is an innate human characteristic. Only through education and recognision of the human condition as imperfect, and agressive can we teach our world's youth what the value of exploring these baser aspects of our species and realizing that we are also capable of amazing compassion and kindness. furthermore, media in every historical era from Anchient Greek Trategy, to Shakespearian histories, to modern crime drama or even chess (a very old game rooted in anchient mele combat) has always explored these aspects of humanity.
I believe that we as a society have to ask why do we enjoy such violence and horror? and by doing so realize something more about ourselves. Many video games lack a certian seriousness which is nessissary to put violence into context. Agression, as opposed to violence, though, is so all pervading that everyday I watch the news and hear of some terrible thing happening to innocent people and it does not supprise me but it does piss me off. Violent games are nothing new nor violence and agression. I believe it is not a matter of just sheltering ourselfs from the horrors of humanity just to be even more shocked when the next disaster of violence erupts, but rather to explore these aspects of our being which requires introspection and education. So young kids should not play violent video games until they are at the age when they are well aquainted with the world they live in, and the beings they are, but neither should they watch violence on TV or watch violence in their own home. Violent gamming is not the real issue its how as a society we deal with violence and just slapping a sticker on a game saying that it is linked to agressive behavior is terribly unfair and misses the point completely... this is an issue of education, society, and above all parenting.
thankyou - (cut and paste adress below for free PDF file, or look up Pediatrics Journal and within site search video games and violence)
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/122/5/e1067?maxtoshow=&HITS=10&hits=10&RESULTFORMAT=&fulltext=video+games+and+violence&searchid=1&FIRSTINDEX=0&sortspec=relevance&resourcetype=HWCIT (cut and paste)
sorry if address doesnt work guess Im not as comp savy as I thouht
this article has some good info in it aswell
http://news.msu.edu/story/337/
Log in to comment