I hope they do FPS reviews need to be comared to other FPS on the market, platformers to platformers and so on. It real hard to say where these reviewers come up with thier scores. I do know thier are some reviewers out there that will give a game an unfair review if it isnt a FPS and thats a ton of crap
So I got this Idea the other day. Why do people always compare games to one another. For example, people on the xbox forums ask which is better COD4 or Assassins Creed? Well, the answer is they are 2 different games. Reviews do the same thing. For example 1up.com, they gave HALO 3 a 10/10 and Mario Galaxy 9.5/10. Ones a FPS obviously the other is a Platformer. I just wanna say one thing, If Mario Galaxy is the Best platform game of all time don't you think it deserves a 10 as well. The problems with reviews is they need to compare games to other games in the same genre and base thier ratings off of that. That way its a fair review. Halo 3 in my opinion did not deserve a 10 in a market that is crowded with FPS'.I know there had to be alot of fanboyism towards Halo cause it got better ratings than COD4 which is a much better game with a way deeper multiplayer. So heres my challenge to all you game reviewers: Rate your games according to the genre that they are in compared to rating it aginst everything else. That way its a more accurate review and way more fare as well.
Log in to comment