ok i agree with you so much, it should get at least a 7.0 or more the only thing i find wrong about the game is the flashlight for one it isnt that bright but i mean having it on or off really does not change much when u are playing and also i think the story is kinda to straight ford not like the other games where you play it and then you are kinda stumped on what just happened in the end and then it makes you go back to played that game again again and again to find out what happened but no this one for me i still like it its one for my top 5 silent hill games my num 1 is silent hill 2 then next would proably have to be the first silent hill then in 3rd silent hill 3then origins or homecoming but id check out silent hill 3 it seems to be everyones top silent hill pick but be warned to get the story in silent hill 3 you must play the first one because silent hill 3 takes place 17 years after the original silent hill 1 and to like silent hill 4 its based on opinion ipersonally dont like it but for ppl who play it its about a 50 to 50 chance to like it but yah i would check out the first 3 they are amazing and one more thing i no ppl dont like homecoming but it is a very fun game to me its one of my tops adn one more thing shatterd memories sucksssss azzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.