This is what I've been asking myself since i started playing Pokemon Soul Silver days ago.:( I've been struggling to decide choosing between one of these starters:

1. Totodile

2. Cindaquil

Back in the days of the originals Gold and Silver versions I'd choose Totodile as my starter and was thinking of choosing a different one this time around. After choosing Cindaquil and spending 1 hour and 40 minutes i thing it will be better staying with the Cindaquil and getting the other later by trade or I'll be wasting another hour and 40 minutes. I haven't even got the first Badge of eight. So i think i will keep on adventuring with the fire type Cindaquil. :D