Look, this is it. This whole thing boils down to cost. A good pc with a great setup today will set you back a few clams. In a year or 2 you have to upgrade your pc graphics card, possibly more ram etc to keep up with the advances in tech. In a 360 you don't have the high upfront cost and you can play most anything a pc can (save strategy games). The cost with a console is a once in 4/5 years deal and you're set (other than that is the cost of a good HDTV and you can enjoy that outside of games too. If you can do a pc moneywise do it! (I did!) If you can do a 360 do it! (I did!) And piles of games for each! It's all in how much money you can and are willing to spend. I understand each side of this arguement, each has it's good and bad points but in the end who cares? It's all about the games!