So finally me and aubrey completed all the silent hill games for ps2. cause we just happened to find all of them about 2 months ago at a game crazy 20 minutes away from our town. but anyways one thing i do have to say is the further we got, like as in whenever we beat one and went to the next the game play seemed to get more boring. Silent hill 2 is probably the better of the three. good storyline and great game play and is probably the scariest(visually silent hill 4 was scariest) but yeah. silent hill 3 the story was blah but i liked the weapons and the game play was good but its very short and the boss battle was well hard but too simple. and then silent hill 4 was longer then the rest but it just kept going and going and would repeat soooo much. only thing i liked about 4 was the visuals and the story. although confusing at times. so if this is the case i hope silent hill 5 will not continue this trend and make a good game for next gen consoles. but i can only wish.