You were talking as if having multiple rails is a good thing which is wrong.There are pros and cons to both and the very best and most powerful PSU's on the market have only a single 12V rail.Spybot_9
True, many power supplies in high wattage outputs use a single 12v rail, despite UL stating that there should be no more than 240 volt amps on any given output at a single time. But not all high end "most powerful" PSUs use single rail outputs. Of course, that depends on what you discern as a "high end" PSU, and that is relative, but there are plenty of companies that are generally regarded are "high end" PSU manufacturers that have multiple rail high wattage output PSUs.
So find me then??Spybot_9
I'm assuming you meant examples of equal to or greater quality power supplies than corsair at a lesser price. That's not too difficult most of the time. I can typically find better prices on just as good power supplies than corsair at below the 700 watt range. Simply look around. That's cost effective, and more "value" than corsair. Above 700, its a tougher job, as you can indeed find some corsair power supplies that have good list prices. Typically, above 700 is overkill, even if you are running SLI, and frankly, you can never futureproof a computer by buying a larger power supply. More than likely, you'll have to self mod it to make it work on a pin configuration or connector that wasn't available on your power supply at the time of purchase. Therefore, buying a much larger power supply on a home computer usually isn't wise or necessary unless you're buying poor quality or you have voltage regulation concerns. Most people don't.
Which comment was plain wrong?Spybot_9
I was referring to DGFreak's comment about a 620 watt power supply not being able to power Roland123_basic's SLI setup, and referring him to just buy a 500 watt supply. He was wrong. I apologize for implicating you in saying that, because when I wrote the second post I mistakenly thought you had said that. You haven't said anything absurd. My mistake. I just get upset when individuals seeking help on a forum are given poor information and instead of giving some helpful advice or pointing someone in the right directions tell them to "forget you sli setup, just get a 500 watt supply"
The entire point behind multiple +12V rails is to keep the power transferred over any single wire under 240VA (20A at 12V). Any more than that and, supposedly, the risk of fire due to an overloaded wire increases. In fact, the vast majority of multiple rail power supplies don't feature discreet rails. They feature multiple current-limited leads connected to a single 12V source.HowardB
Yes.
The idea that multiple rail power supplies offer better stability, performance, or load balancing is an invention of power supply manufacturers that offer multiple rail power supplies. Other than the safety issue mentioned before, there's no practical advantage to multiple +12V rails. HowardB
No, multiple rail power supplies are not the invention of the power supply manufacturers, it was directed by underwriters laboratory when they were tasked to evaluate and approve power supplies. They were alarmed at the amount of wattage in a single wire that power supply manufacturers were selling to the public. The manufacturers DID jump on board are started using multiple rails as a rally cry and advertising gimmic, even if it wasn't completely true. (the more is better concept)
No, there has not been a significant amount of reported or validated increased it power supply failure, either standard or catastrophic from single rail high wattage power supplies, because the UL mandate forced power supply manufacturers to either use multiple voltage carrying rails from a single source, or use better guage wire and safer construction in higher wattage power supplies to avoid the risk of failure. A majority of the manufactures have done so, from what I know. I don't regularly examine power supplies outside of my list of trusted manufacturers, so I can't say in all honesty what's going on in the budget psu area.
If you are buying a power supply, and you don't have practical knowledge of what you're getting, I still beleive that getting a multiple rail supply is the safer bet.
Log in to comment