Pros:
- Massive map
- Lifelike graphics
- Incredible animations
- Story *
- Acting
- Depth of story (characters, metaphors, allegories)
- Pace
- Atmosphere **
- Amount of content
- Violence
- Mission design
- Hunting
- Customization
- Horse bonding
- Characters
- Cinematography
- And more...
Cons:
- Ridiculous, unwarranted bounties
- Somewhat frequent bugs
- Automatically chooses weapons for missions *
- Bullet holes in hats
- (how many times can you get shot in the head and survive?)
- Deletes outfits/removes them from horse in annoying ways
Rating:
- Story ********** 10/10
- Gameplay ********** 10/10
- Atmosphere ********** 10/10
- Overall ********** 10/10
————————————————
- Story (characters, narrative, depth, pace, role playing)
- Gameplay (mechanics, fun factor, customization, level design)
- Atmosphere (graphics, environment, mood)