The problem is ppl giving 10/10 all over the place.
Theres something for everyone to enjoy. Side-missions (optional), moral choices, exploration, you also have a great deal of liberty... start shooting everyone in a saloon for example... Why I don't give it a ten relies on 2 things. First: The controls are not top notch, and The graphics could've been better (uncharted 2). I really enjoyed the game so far, and I am looking forward to complete it. I did not play online though, so my review is not complete in a sense... Still, I wanted to share my experience...
Great game, you can buy with your eyes closed...