The Good. The Bad. The Ugly.
The Good: Graphics look pretty nice. When you ride your horse through canyons or dessert, you really appreciate the developers time on the visuals. When you shoot a gun, it just feels right, the feel of the rumble in your controller to your character getting pushed back by your good ol' Red Rider or whatever.A decent amount of stuff to do such as quest are given to you throughout the game. Multiplayer is more fun then expected. Storyline isn't as bad as I thought it was going to be.
The Bad. A few glitches here and there. You can't customize your character very well. You can't enhance your weapons or anything. The whole riding the horse thing is fun, for 20min! I found that having to ride your horse across the level all the time just gets insanely boring.
The Ugly. This is what brought the score down, this whole game is BEEN THERE, DONE THAT. I'm talking about how there wasn't really any break through with Rockstar developing it. Its GTA with a different skin on. After a couple of hours my reaction to the game was: damn, I rented this game for how many days?
Overall, this is the best Western game fix your going to get. It's good, just not great.