RDR shoots you down but in a good way!
Graphics- I don't have the greatest TV in the world and the graphics still look incredible! By far some of the best in gaming history. The enviroment and landscape is the best thing graphical wise about this game but the character models, buildings, animals, and guns look incredible as well.
Gameplay- The gameplay may take a little time to get used to but in time you will become the Master Shooter in or out of Dead eye mode.
Story- The best thing about this game the story of RDR is very superb to most if not all games out there today. I won't give away anything about it so I won't spoil it. The story is so engaging and good you'll get side tracked but will really want to do another story mission to see what happens next.
Replayability- This depends if you have Online play availible or not. If you don't it isn't a total loss since all of the side challenges and missions will keep you playing as well as the forever great story of the game. If you do have Online play availible to you then Congrats! Cause it just adds to the fun.
Fun Factor- Not the most consistentely exciting game out there when actually playing though it will have many moments like that.
Overall- Red Dead Redemption is well worth the $60 or so price and is just a wild time!