Being a copy cat means you shouldn't buy it? I say thats rubbish!
Graphics, yes were all graphic whores at some point in our life, Saints Row is definitely not one of the best looking games, but for what it is, being a huge open world game, its damn good. It has a very clean, realistic look, but the art style is more on the cartoonish side, if that makes any sense. Textures overall are good to great, some better than others, but lots of variety, something else that really impressed me was the weather, it does a very convincing overcast/stormy day, theres also different levels of intensity. Moving onto character models, there quite decent for the art style it went for, I think it did a good job, although if you make a crappy looking character, don't blame it on the game having crappy models! Overall, minus some pop in and wierd graphical glitches, the visuals are great.
Sound is a important aspect as well, the track selection isn't as elite as say the GTA series, but its definitely a good B + soundtrack, some stuff you'll reconize, most you won't, that doesn't mean you won't come away with a new favorite song though. Ambient sounds are decent as well, hearing a blasting system coming down the street is surprisingly realistic sounding, also with changing frequencys as you enter and get out of your car is very convincing. The most improved sound related issue when it came to GTA's cap gun sounding guns, is definitely more than improved in Saints Row, guns all sound good and make them all the more fun to shoot, with each having its own unique sound. Overall the sound is good, not the best sounding ever in a game but its not bad at all.
Multi-player, I got the game kind of early you might say, so there wasn't a good amount of people on to play against, but from what I can tell its solid, nothing revolutionary but good none the less. One cool thing is being able to customize your character online as well, you earn money from playing games to upgrade your character wich makes it a little addicting to keep playing. When I play this, even though its a completely different setting, I get the Socom vibe in a weird way, maybe its just the third person view that does it, I don't know. Theres also co-op wich I have yet to experience, but it is there. If your buying this game for the multiplayer alone, I would rent it first, not because it sucks, but because it might not be everybodys style.
Overall this is a better than average game, its great! There are so many improvements it makes on the genre, that hopefully, more dev's in this genre will look at, and even improve more on. Now there are some things that it could of used like motorcycles! No airplanes ok, ill cut them a break, motorcycles were one of the best things about GTA VC and SA, they left them out *sigh* I guess that will be on my wishlist for SR 2!