Shadow of the Colossus..the most amazing game on any system, ever witnessed by anyone...bar none!
My only beef is with the Gamespot resident reviewer, I am sure if this were an XBOX OR XBOX360 release, this would have made Editors Choice, with a resounding 9.9 (nothing is perfect). The reviewer makes essentially the same claim about the game as my observation, than kicks it with an 8.7 (what!). The intelligent user reviews have made similar observations and rated the game accordingly.
Lest you think I am a PS2 Weenie or have a burning desire to pontificate about the consoles and PCs we have and use frequently ( PS2, XBOX, XBOX360, Gamecube, PSP, a host of Gaming PCs. [we do love our games]) that is not the intent; this game is great compared to anything available on anything.
The only question I have is why I continue to be a member of Gamespot Complete. The reviewers smack of Microsoft Weinerness (< possibly, a new word), and this is not the first time this has been observed at Gamespot.
While I ponder the question, my rating for the game, Shadow of the Colossus is 9.7 and for the Gamespot wiener review, 0.3 (nothing is perfect or completely lame).
Ziek