This is the text-book definition of survivial horror.
At first, SH2 may seem like a cliche survival horror game. It does have all the familiar elements. But behind the sometimes flimsy dialogue and frustrating camera angles, there's something beautiful and unique that separates this game from others in its genre.
As James (the story's protagonist), you'll make your way throughout the foggy, deserted West Virginian town, in search of your late wife. Occasionally, James will be pitted against some of the most well-rendered and disturbing creatures to ever grace the PS2. But fighting seems to take the backseat. And although this slightly nullifies the "survival" aspect, it does little to soothe the mind's ease. In fact, the most memorable part of the game is the psychological downhill spiral the gamer takes.
The lack of fighting allows for the gamer to enjoy, or barely stomach, the storyline. James also encounters quite a few puzzles, many of which deal with the shady background of Silent Hill. In this, Konami successfully found another character in the town, only further enhancing the plot.
At the end of the game, first time game players will probably experience a less than endearing ending. There are many more (depending on the SH2 version you have), but the game stays away from the "happily ever after" routine. Instead, they make the game seem as if it is one, long, sad story. Which it is. Character development is strong too. James doesnt portray the average gun-toting machismo stereotype most survival horror protagonists get. He's practically normal. During the game, the storyline takes a huge turn the first time you experience the "nightmare" version of your surroundings. Whereas I figured this was James's inability to discern between two realities, my friends figured it was the town's two faces.
Silent Hill 1's ending had many people scratching their heads. Rightfully so, seeing as some of the endings were completely confusing. In SH2, you pretty much get the picture of what happened. However, the ending is also left open for interpretation, which leaves much to ponder about the town in relationship with James's character, past, and mental state.
In the end, no matter what is resolved for the gamer, you wind up with a piece of well crafted material. Amidst the darkness and disturbing images, there's also sense of beauty, both within the town's serene layout and the relationship between James and his late wife. Where other games have locked in on the fighting sequences, SH2 does the genre some justice in keeping it simple, and lets the story grab the steering wheel and drive.