What starts nice, doesn't always ends nice...
User Rating: 4.6 | Silent Hill 4: The Room PC
To be sincere, this is the first game of the series I played, but I can say that the game is just a copy of the PS2 version, just edited for PC use... Well, the gameplay and control system is absolutely stupid. It is very difficult to manuoevre the player properly... Also, while the graphics in videos are very nice, the in game graphics are a big dissapointment. Sounds are good, in general. The combat and the save systems just suck... I recently started playing SH3, and I noticed that you can save whenever and wherever you want. In SH4, this is not an option! As for the storyline, I won't say anything, because it is a matter of opinion... Personally, I found it somewhat odd...
Concluding, I believe that it could far a better game than it ended up to be... 
