Homecoming is a great addition to the Silent Hill franchise, a must play for fans of the survival horror genre.
There were, however, a few things that I did not like about the game. The game was entirely too short and therefore the size and scope of the game suffered. The combat system needed more attention, I found myself not even using the guns in the game that much (may have just been me). I also thought the graphics could have been better for the auxiliary characters during the cinematic sequences, seems like they didn't pay much attention to certain characters.
None of these negatives affected the storyline, which in a game like this is crucial and is the whole reason I play these games. The game is nice addition to the Silent Hill mythology.