Very good, However I am dissapointed at how short it is, I will add that Bentley, and Murray have improved greatly.
Graphics: Not bad Cartoonish I will add. But it's the best graphics I've seen in this series. I love the fact that the safehouses are more elaborate. One thing I miss is the old bugging, and listening into the conversations of the bosses.
Gameplay: Not bad, I love it actually. The new characters are awesome, I love that you can play as a character that can posess people. That brings up a great point, You should've been able to play as the whole gang, but you can't Just Sly, Bentley, and Murray.
Overall: 9.5 For it's terrificness! Please don't worry about the renting of this game, Just buy it!