For the love of God...
Look at Gamespots first paragraph for the Dreamcast version of this game, and then look at this version. You would never think that they were talking about the same game.
But they are.
This is a fun, funky adventure game with one of the world's most famous gaming mascots, with a fantastic soundtrack and a very well made mission structure. Okay, the Knuckles missions are a load of tripe but once you look past that you have an interesting platformer with cool characters and a brilliant level design. And when all's said and done it's the same game as the Dreamcast original with an extended multiplayer mode. So how does that score less?
Sort out your reviewing system, Gamespot.
Andy Fenn