Don't knock it till you try it.
Graphics: 7
Alright, they aren't the best graphics that the wii is capable of but they do have some little features. The frame rate on this game is amazing, you can swing at top speed thru NYC and the game doesn't slow down at all. The lighting effects make a small impact but it is nice to know that they thought of it. However, there are some bad parts to these, for example, there is little diversity in anything from buildings to people(who often times there voice doesnt atch their gender but thats another issue)
Sound: 5
There is very little music in the game (no music when youre just swingin around) the civillians voices may not match their gender and the accents are terrible. On the bright side the main characters are voiced by the actors with the exception of Kirsten Dunst. but none of them seem to excited. Spider-man's taunts are fun the first time but after a while it just gets repetitive the sopund of the web is good though!
Replay Value: 9
The advantage in replay value here is that it is a relatively short game so you want to go back and up the difficulty or try to complete the game in a faster time this bieng a short game you can do that. there is also a lot to do after you beat the story. You can rid NYC of all the gangs, search for Spider Emblems, or meteorites and beat your time in all the challenges.
Tilt: 9
Granted i'm a huge fan of Spider-man so i may tend to be a little biased in this review nevertheless i try to be as fair as I can.
Gameplay: 8
I found this game fun to play from swinging around to fight ing the bosses. The bosses are all unique which makes them all the more fun. They each give you a sense of an epic fight between Spidey and whoever the boss happens to be. The fighting system works well. it's nice to see that they actually thought about the wiimote and made it work.
Conclusion: 8
I hope this review helps if even a little but this is just an honest review from a Spider-man fan who actually loved this game.