Alot of bugs, unoptimized & underpowered engine, short SP and marijuanahigh hype partially ruined this game for me..
Engine eats away your PC and its not exactly eyecandy (I was able tu run it smoothly on extra high on my rig, but alot of my friends didnt reach high).
Lets face it - this game was turbo hyped and it didnt turn out to be turbohype worthy!
If it was only a finished product i might have agreed with gamespot on their hype-led 8.5 :)
The games atmosphere and gameplay really rock and I'm kinda sorry to see these shortcomings in other areas - if it werent for them I would love this game till the end of time. It kinda makes me sad to see all this potential only halfway exploited :(