Nice to play, not too hard, not too easy. A bit repetitive over time. Thought 3D would suck, but it hasn't !
Needs more actions like: use with, pull/push/grab, talk/eat/use-mouth and examine (even if its something you dont have in your inventory). Also it misses the action "use with guybrush" like clicking yourself. All this makes the game very easy sometimes, just click everything and it will grab, touch, lick or do whatever is needed.
Voice acting is excellent. The story, even if really crazy/magic, is cool too.
It's missing something to do in real time, like a mini game. Like in MI 3 when you have to sink ships.
Much better than MI 4, but it doesn't compare with the mythic MI 3.