Even with the awkward controls and glitches, I found myself highly addicted to playing this game!
Graphics: 7.5/10 - Nothing amazing, but the game does look like the comic book, which is what Telltale was aiming for. The game looks simple, yet there are still constant hiccups when the game is loading your choices into the story. The Walking Dead lacks that final polish, and it's noticeable.
Story: 10/10 - This is why The Walking Dead was voted Game of the Year. (I personally wouldn't, since I believe games should be graded by more than just storylines) However, this game has one of the most well-told stories in any game that I've played. The character development, the excitement, the twists that the TV series is well known for can be found here as well. This is what kept me playing, and as soon as I finished a chapter, I couldn't wait to play the next one. Yes, It's that good.
Animations: 8/10 - The characters a pretty well animated (no motion-capture here) but they do feel a bit stiff at times. The facial expressions on each character are pretty well done also.
Final note: If Telltale would have added that extra bit of polish to the game, this would have been a perfect experience. I wish that the game wouldn't have those constant pauses, or the high amount of glitches that I experienced through just my first playthrough, then this game would have received higher marks. Unfortunately, this game is plagued with problems; but that shouldn't keep you from experiencing one of the best stories in gaming to date.